HOW NONPROFITS CAN PLAN FOR THE FUTURE WITHOUT PREDICTING IT

 

The ink was barely dry on a nonprofit's newly approved strategic plan when a tornado ripped through town, tearing the air handling units off the roof and leaving a gaping hole in the building.

At an emergency board meeting, one board member remarked, "Well, I guess that strategic plan we just approved isn't going to help us much now."

Except it did.

Why Strategic Planning Matters More in a Changing World

One of my favorite strategic planning quotes can be attributed to Dwight D. Eisenhower. In 1950, Eisenhower stated in a letter: “Peace-time plans are of no particular value, but peace-time planning is indispensable”. At the heart of his message is this: the value of planning lies not in the final plan itself, but in the process of planning and the skills that are developed as a result of that process. Much has changed since the 1950s, and today’s pace of change feels relentless. That is why the very exercise of flexing our “planning muscle” gives us the opportunity to prepare for uncertainty, grow as strategic thinkers, and become more adaptable as an organization.

What Is Strategic Planning for Nonprofits?

At its core, strategic planning is about aligning an organization's mission, priorities, resources, and actions. It requires leaders to look inward at organizational strengths and challenges, outward at community needs and emerging trends, and forward to determine where the organization can make the greatest impact.

The greatest value of strategic planning isn't the document it produces. It's the strategic thinking, shared understanding, and decision-making discipline that the process develops.

Strategic Planning vs. Predicting the Future

When circumstances change, the first question shouldn't be whether the strategic plan is still relevant. It should be what needs to change—and what needs to remain constant—to continue advancing the mission.

With the nonprofit impacted by the tornado, the mission had not changed. Neither had the community’s needs. The facility just wasn’t going to be the vehicle for how they delivered on the objectives of the plan. This story is a powerful reminder that we can’t predict the future, but we can use the process and the resulting plan to anchor the nonprofit in what matters. The organization would go on to serve the community in the same way it had intended, it would just need to do it differently than they’d originally planned.

How to Build an Adaptable Nonprofit Strategic Plan

Here are three suggestions for building an adaptable plan.

  1. Build your planning muscle. Embrace the process, ask difficult questions, challenge assumptions, and resist rushing to conclusions. The more leaders practice strategic thinking, the better prepared they'll be when circumstances change.
  2. Create a roadmap, not a rigid script to a certain destination. Establish clear goals and measurable outcomes but recognize that strategies and tactics may need to evolve. The destination can remain the same even when the route changes due to a detour.
  3. Look beyond what's immediately in front of you. Don't just examine current conditions. Grab your binoculars and look for emerging trends, potential disruptions, and opportunities on the horizon. Make environmental scanning an ongoing board and staff practice rather than a once-every-few-years exercise.

Signs Your Nonprofit Strategy Needs to Change

Besides an unforeseen event, there may be other hints that the strategy needs to change. Tracking key performance indicators and measurable goals will tell leaders when a shift is needed because reality is off course with predicted targets. Sometimes a return to the practice of planning will result in a new set of strategies to meet the same goal, just differently and more effectively.

Here are a few other indicators that strategy needs to be revisited besides metrics falling short:

  • Community needs are shifting or emerging in unexpected ways.
  • Funding, staffing, or other resources no longer support the original approach.
  • New opportunities or partnerships have emerged.
  • External conditions have changed significantly.

You Can't Predict What's Next—But You Can Prepare for It

The future will always bring surprises. Some will create opportunities. Others will test an organization's resilience in ways no one could have anticipated.

The goal of strategic planning isn't to eliminate uncertainty. It's to build the clarity, alignment, and adaptability needed to navigate it.

Because the most valuable strategic plan isn't one that predicts what will happen next. It's one that helps an organization know what to do when the unexpected happens.

 

Your strategy should do more than guide your organization. It should strengthen your ability to deliver on your mission. Let's talk about the impact you want to create and the strategy that will help you get there. Contact DBD Group to get started today.

Posted by Leighann Sibal
Leighann Sibal

Written by Leighann Sibal

Leighann Sibal serves as a consultant and thought partner to nonprofit organizations, inspiring innovative and strategic approaches to thrive in today’s challenging business environment. Her expertise in planning, board development, capital readiness and collaborations allow her to support to nonprofit organizations in their quest to meaningfully address existing and emerging community needs.

Our Latest Posts

Subscribe